Midwest Living Holiday Gift Guide 2020
Buying gifts from indie shops and artists in our communities is a win-win-win—and who doesn't want a small victory to cap off 2020? Here are our staff's picks. Pro tip: Shop early, as small makers sometimes sell out.
1 of 30
Midwesty Tee
MARY-BETH ROUSE, CREATIVE DIRECTOR
Dubuque, Iowa Our whole staff (except, maybe, our lead copy editor, who is still wondering if Midwesty is a word) has become superfans of The Midwest Girl, a brand developed by two sisters, selling tees, snuggly sweatshirts, trucker caps and more. $28. shopthemidwestgirl.com
1 of 30
2 of 30
Map Planter
KYLEE KRIZMANIC, EDITOR IN CHIEF
St. Louis I love how the custom maps on Malaika Tolford's stoneware look almost abstract. And as a dedicated plant mama, I also appreciate that she offers a choice on drainage holes! From $45. etsy.com
2 of 30
3 of 30
Single-Origin Chocolate Bars
NICK CROW, CREATIVE DIRECTOR
Petoskey, Michigan The trifecta! First, the company name: Crow & Moss. How could I resist a namesake bar? (Wink.) Second, I love the colorfully modern packaging. And third, the quality. The bars are made in small batches, with very good, very dark chocolate. One square is the perfect treat to lift me from an afternoon slump. $9. crowandmoss.com
3 of 30
4 of 30
Otrio
MADELAINE JEROUSEK-SMITH, COPY EDITOR
Highland Park, Illinois This tic-tac-toe-like game is one of my family's favorites. (Upholstery on a corporate cafeteria booth inspired this game!) We own the original multicolor version (available all over the Internet) but this luxe walnut Inventor's Edition? Drool. $100. otrio.com
4 of 30
5 of 30
Entwined Necklace
KYLEE KRIZMANIC, EDITOR IN CHIEF
Eau Claire, Wisconsin I love Hello Adorn's delicate jewelry. Proceeds from the Entwined necklace benefit racial justice organizations. From $36. helloadorn.com
5 of 30
6 of 30
Forged Skillet
HANNAH AGRAN, EXECUTIVE EDITOR
Logan, Ohio A Hocking Hills family forges 10-inch skillets that are naturally nonstick, thinner and lighter than most cast iron, and have long handles that stay cool longer. They're a big splurge. But these pans will last generations, and I love feeling the character and history that come with an ancient craft each time I grip the handle. $250. themakersofhandforgediron.com
6 of 30
7 of 30
Sleep Masks
MARY BEAUMONT, DEPUTY EDITOR
Sheboygan Falls, Wisconsin Light wakes me, and my husband gets up at 4 a.m., so I depend on sleep masks—and these are the best, with adjustable straps and, for $4 extra, silk backs. See you in the morning. From $20. houseoflanguor.com
7 of 30
8 of 30
Teardrop Vases
EMILY BERGER, MWL PHOTOGRAPHER
Detroit Pewabic is a heritage ceramic studio (started in 1903 by a woman!), and their signature iridescent glazes are so unique. Each one is different, and they look as fetching today as a century ago. (Pewabic operates as a nonprofit and offers classes in its historic facility.) $150. pewabic.com
8 of 30
9 of 30
Custom Football
CYNTHIA EARHART, MWL WRITER
Ada, Ohio At its rural headquarters, Wilson manufactures every single football used in the NFL. And they'll hand-stitch balls for ordinary folks, too, with a custom family name, player number or message printed on the leather. From $95. wilson.com
9 of 30
10 of 30
Sea Salt Caramels
KARYN SPENCER, MWL WRITER
Omaha One reason to look forward to winter: The Perennial Homestead's caramels. Ali Yahnke makes luscious, buttery candy from her grandpa's recipe, but only October through February. From $15. theperennialhomestead.com
10 of 30
11 of 30
The Bellfield Crossbody
KYLEE KRIZMANIC, EDITOR IN CHIEF
Cleveland This roomy leather bag is one of my most prized treasures and has developed a gorgeous patina over time. $380. fountleather.com
11 of 30
12 of 30
Maple Syrup
KRISTIN BIENERT, EDITORIAL CONTENT MANAGER
Thompsonville, Michigan The fifth-generation Griner family taps maple trees along the Betsie River, and the syrup ages in Iron Fish Distillery barrels, for hints of oak and bourbon. Tastes greats on pancakes or late-night ice cream. $20. ironfishdistillery.com
12 of 30
13 of 30
Bath Bombs
AMANDA DOYLE, MWL WRITER
I have never, ever used a better bath bomb than the ones from Provenance Soapworks in Saint Charles,Missouri. (And I've tried a lot!) They are beautifully packaged, super-moisturizing and the scent lasts. From $4. provenancesoaps.com
13 of 30
14 of 30
Creatures of the Order Prints
HANNAH AGRAN, EXECUTIVE EDITOR
Minneapolis I have coveted illustrator Kelsey Oseid's zoology posters for years—but, oh, the choices! Do I go for the one of all the penguins? The butterflies? Maybe the rabbits. Or that funky new one with the squids and octopi? I might just need to give in to a gallery wall. From $20. kelzuki.com
14 of 30
15 of 30
Faceted Mugs
KYLEE KRIZMANIC, EDITOR IN CHIEF
Glenwood, Iowa Danielle Whigham's work sells fast. I can't wait to snag a pair of these mugs. $38. dwhighamceramics.etsy.com
15 of 30
16 of 30
Cedar Trays
MARY-BETH ROUSE, CREATIVE DIRECTOR
St. Cloud, Minnesota Pair one of these slatted handmade gardening trays with packages of microgreen seeds, like radish, kale or broccoli. It's a nutritious, fun gift that will keep giving all winter long. (Johnny's Selected Seeds has a huge assortment, with growing tips.) Wood seed trays are a green alternative to plastic. This one's about 1 foot long. $40. prettysimpleshoppe.etsy.com
16 of 30
17 of 30
Tea Towels
ALLISON VANCURA, CONTENT EDITOR
Berkley, Michigan Colorful, vintage-style botanicals matched with soft, absorbent cotton: precisely what one needs and wants in a kitchen towel. A husband-wife team runs the shop; she designs the prints, and there are dozens to choose from. (If you like these towels, you'll also love June and December's notepads and stationery.) $16. junedecember.com
17 of 30
18 of 30
Frankie Oil Bottle
ALLISON ZELLE, ASSOCIATE ART DIRECTOR
Prairie Village, Kansas Golden and Pine, located near my house, is my one-stop shop for handmade gifts. I'm especially smitten by their pottery pieces, like this oil dispenser, made right here in Kansas City by artist Sarah Veak. (Olive oil should be kept away from light, so this is good on your food and your eyes.) From $62. goldenandpine.com
18 of 30
19 of 30
Fair-Trade Hats
MARY-BETH ROUSE, CREATIVE DIRECTOR
Designed in Lafayette, Indiana, and knit by women in Nepal, these fair-trade hats are made of wool or mohair, with a fleece lining. They come in a rainbow of hues and patterns. From $42. frenchknot.com
19 of 30
20 of 30
Wall Clock
KYLEE KRIZMANIC, EDITOR IN CHIEF
Detroit Tait clocks are impeccably designed and assembled in Michigan of solid maple and all-American parts. They come in five juicy colors. I imagine placing this one in my kitchen above the pantry door—our own private sunshine as we're milling about in the morning. (If a 14-inch wall clock is too big, Tait makes a mini desktop version.) $185. taitdesignco.com
20 of 30
21 of 30
Ceramic Tea Set
SHAUNA SEVER, MWL RECIPE CONTRIBUTOR
Chicago Angela Venarchik's gorgeous, sturdy ceramics have turned me from vintage shopper into artsy ceramics obsessive. She does sell smaller pieces, but this Great Lakes Collection tea set, inspired by cracked ice? Sigh. $178. angelavenarchik.com
21 of 30
22 of 30
Australian-Style Licorice
JESS HOFFERT, PROJECTS EDITOR
Perham, Minnesota Wiley Wallaby's big, addictive hunks of licorice are soft, flavorful and have less sugar than most. Plus, who could resist that name? Huckleberry and Classic Red are my faves. From $4.50. wileywallaby.com
22 of 30
23 of 30
Sea Salt Scrub
KYLEE KRIZMANIC, EDITOR IN CHIEF
Traverse City, Michigan I already tried Thistle + Grey soap; now I'm jonesing for this rosemary-lavender scrub. $18. thistleandgreyshop.etsy.com
23 of 30
24 of 30
Weaving Kits
KELSEY OGLETREE, MWL WRITER
Minneapolis Do I weave? Nope. Do these lovely kits make my fingers twitch? 100 percent. Available in three sizes, they include all the supplies for a trendy wall hanging. And when I become the textile artist I'm sure I am inside, I can buy more yarn to start again. From $87. oakeandashe.com
24 of 30
25 of 30
Peppermint Fudge Sauce
ERIN KEEFFER, SENIOR GRAPHIC DESIGNER
Galena, Illinois This go-to gift from my hometown is incredible on ice cream, but to be completely honest, the sauce doesn't usually make it that far. Straight from the jar is my preferred method of enjoyment. $7. galenacanning.com
25 of 30
26 of 30
Soy Candles
KYLEE KRIZMANIC, EDITOR IN CHIEF
Leelanau County, Michigan A scent called Woodsmoke + Apple? Color me cozy. $18. farmhousecandlecompany.com
26 of 30
27 of 30
Pottery Dishes
GINGER CRICHTON, SENIOR EDITOR
Minneapolis artist Kerry Brooks' mini dishes are sobeautiful and sparkly! I bought coasters from her as a road trip souvenir this summer. $12 each. dock6pottery.com
27 of 30
28 of 30
Custom Stationery
HANNAH AGRAN, EXECUTIVE EDITOR
Walhalla, North Dakota Lacee Swan illustrates whimsical stationery for all ages. Choose a setting, then customize skin color, hair style and extras, like coffee or glasses. I had such fun ordering notecards for the tween in my life. From $25. laceeswan.com
28 of 30
29 of 30
Peach Black Tea
KYLEE KRIZMANIC, EDITOR IN CHIEF
Des Moines Five percent of Blk and Bold's coffee and tea sales support youth programming, work development and eradicating homelessness. $12. blkandbold.com
29 of 30
30 of 30
Click & Done: Gifts You Can't Wrap
Check out these outside-the-box presents that keep dollars local when our communities need us most.
DEBBIE MILLER, MWL WRITER
CSA SHARES A community-supported agriculture share is a weekly or biweekly box of fresh produce, picked up from a farmer, spring through fall. It's pricey (usually several hundred dollars), but how about offering to chip in on one for a relative who loves to cook?
GARY THOMPSON, SENIOR STAFF WRITER
GIFT CARDS You're not being lazy or giving up. With gift cards, you're giving people permission to splurge on themselves. Sleuth out favorite restaurants, breweries or boutiques of friends and relatives, so they can have fun and support a small business.
BRENDA KIENAST, ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT
MEMBERSHIPS I've often given zoo and museum memberships to my daughter's family. It might feel weird this year, but think of it as giving a charitable gift in the recipient's name, for a resource they love and want to keep alive—and may enjoy later in 2021.
DIANE PENNINGROTH, LEAD COPY EDITOR
FOOD SUBSCRIPTIONS Cheese. Bacon. Chocolate. You name it, someone will ship it to you regularly. My own monthly treat: Chicago's Dark Matter Coffee. The labels are works of art, and the beans are some of the best around.