The Midwest's Best Cookie Recipes

By The editors of MidwestLiving.com
Updated August 08, 2020

Indulge in 40 mouthwatering cookie recipes from Midwest Living readers, Midwest restaurants and our own Test Kitchen.

Start Slideshow

1 of 46

Salty Caramel and Pecan Oatmeal Cookies

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

These cookies come with a friendly warning: Chewy caramel, toasted pecans and a flurry of sea salt will make you popular. Very popular. A product called caramel bits gives these cookies great flavor and chewy texture. Some supermarkets carry them, and they're widely available online. (Search for Kraft Caramel Bits.) Take care to follow recipe directions when baking: caramel bits melt quickly.

Advertisement
Advertisement

2 of 46

Peanut Better Blossoms

Blaine Moats
View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

In her book Midwest Made: Big, Bold Baking from the Heartland, Shauna Sever ramped up the nuttiness and opted for a creamy ganache filling in her take on this Midwest favorite.

3 of 46

Cocoa and Brown Butter Shortbread Bites

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

Browned butter infuses irresistible nuttiness into these four-ingredient cookies without sullying their essential simplicity or sandy texture. Dip them in satiny chocolate for effortless glamor.

Advertisement

4 of 46

Caramel Apple Cookies

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

Chopped apple, pecans, apple juice, apple pie spice and more combine for a hearty, delicious cookie. The frosting and nuts add just the right touch of sweetness and crunch on top.

5 of 46

Peanut Butter Temptations

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

Calling all peanut butter fans! These cookies offer double-the-PB compared to the classic peanut blossom cookie with a chocolate kiss on top. And they couldn't be easier.

6 of 46

Gingersnap Gems

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

The recipe for these sweet and spicy cookies comes from the Warren family in Stanley, Kansas. The gingersnaps are a favorite at family gatherings.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

7 of 46

Gramma's Sugar Cookies

Blaine Moats
View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

Shauna Sever grew up thinking this beloved recipe was special to her family with its unique additions of vegetable oil, confectioners' sugar and cream of tartar. So you can imagine her bewilderment when she found this exact recipe in a vintage Illinois state cookbook. This recipe is in her book Midwest Made: Big, Bold Baking from the Heartland as well.

8 of 46

Coconut Macaroons

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

In all our years of testing, we've rarely found a cookie recipe as crazy-simple as this reliable crowd-pleaser. These cookies taste great au naturel--but dipping the bottoms in chocolate adds easy decadence (and looks eye-catching on a cookie tray).

9 of 46

S'More Cookies, Please

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

Cinnamon, brown sugar, oats and finely crushed grahams shape this moist cookie made even more irresistible with a thumbprint filling of marshmallow creme and an upside-down milk chocolate candy.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

10 of 46

Pie Cookies

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

At Sister Pie in Detroit, they make these buttery, buttercream- or ganache-filled sandwich cookies from scraps of dough leftover from making pies. You can do the same, storing them in the freezer until you have enough. Or just make a fresh batch of pastry-it's worth it! The recipe comes from cafe owner Lisa Ludwinski's debut cookbook, Sister Pie.

11 of 46

Mindy Segal's Chocolate Chip Cookies

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

These to-die-for cookies use special chocolate and two kinds of salt, and they call for an overnight chill-and you can absolutely taste the difference. Because of the expense and time involved, we don't recommend them for any old weekend, but they are incredible for a gift or other special occasion. The recipe comes from Chicago chef Mindy Segal's cookbook Cookie Love.

12 of 46

Peanut Butter Munchies

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

A Hanover, Kansas, reader sent the recipe for these chocolate cookies with peanut butter centers to a Midwest Living® cookie contest. A judge described them as "regally rich chocolate with a peanut butter kick."

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

13 of 46

Lindsay's Chocolate Cafe Chocolate Chip Cookies

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

This cookie, from the former Lindsay's Chocolate Cafe and Coffee House in O'Fallon, Missouri, wowed us with its flavor-packed lineup of ingredients. "These are the best chocolate chip cookies I have ever had! " says one of our website reviewers. "These are wonderful with a glass of cold milk while the cookie is still warm!"

14 of 46

Our Own Dream Cookies

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

It's not easy satisfying everyone, but this cookie from the Midwest Living® Test Kitchen tries to meet the challenge! It's packed with oatmeal, chocolate, peanut butter and nuts.

15 of 46

Miss Rosa Lee’s Oatmeal Cookies

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

Nothing fancy here; this is the perfectly chewy lunchbox classic, pebbled with walnuts and plump raisins. A combination of vegetable oil and butter ensures a chewy texture and rich flavor. This recipe comes from Patty Pinner's cookbook Sweets (crownpublishing.com).

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

16 of 46

Lemon-Pecan Shortbread Cookies

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

Irresistible tangy lemon and rich pecans flavor one of the easiest cookies around: buttery shortbread. Serve with a cool dish of ice cream in the summer or a hot cup of tea in winter.

17 of 46

Mrs. Truman's Coconut Cookies

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

Here's our version of Bess Truman's coconut cookie recipe from the Truman Library in Independence, Missouri. We added the fruit.

18 of 46

Honey-Rosemary Shortbread Cookies

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

Chicago chef Myk Banas created these utterly delicious and subtly sophisticated cookies.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

19 of 46

Orange-Ginger Cookie Sandwiches

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

A round cookie cutter with scalloped edges makes a nice shape for these cookies, but bell, tree or star cutters would also be good choices for the holidays.

20 of 46

Opal's Walnut Shortbread Cookies

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

Patrick Groth, owner-chef of Incredibly Delicious bakery in Springfield, Illinois, uses his grandmother's recipe for these cookies. "Use the best walnuts you have and fresh butter," he advises.

21 of 46

Polvorones

Blaine Moats
View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

Polvorones are Mexico's crispy, airy answer to shortbread (you may know them as Mexican wedding cookies). Midwest food writer Shauna Sever coats them in cinnamon sugar for a churro-like effect.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

22 of 46

Fantasy Chocolate-Caramel Delights

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

"I love caramel, nuts and chocolate," says the Mandan, North Dakota, reader who sent this recipe to a Midwest Living® cookie contest. Fantasy Chocolate-Caramel Delights were one of the highest-rated cookies in the contest.

23 of 46

Chocolatey Shortbread Bites

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

Because this recipe makes so many cookies, you might want to freeze some dough for future use. Store in an airtight container in refrigerator for up to one week. Or freeze in a freezer container for up to 6 months; thaw in refrigerator before use.

24 of 46

Sandbakkels

Blaine Moats
View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

Sandbakkels means "sand tarts" because the cookies (which, flipped over, can double as tiny shells to hold cream and fruit) have such a fine, crisp texture. Find them in Shauna Sever's book Midwest Made: Big, Bold Baking from the Heartland.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

25 of 46

Lebkuchen

Blaine Moats
View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

The secret to perfect lebkuchen is in the resting phase after glazing. An apple wedge in the storage container provides moisture that softens the cookies. This German classic is from Shauna Sever's book Midwest Made: Big, Bold Baking from the Heartland.

26 of 46

Double Chocolate-Cherry Cookies

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

Carol Schneider of Wausau, Wisconsin, brought home a blue ribbon when she entered these cookies at the Wisconsin State Fair. The recipe combines white and semisweet chocolate with dried cherries and walnuts.

27 of 46

Kansas Sunflower Cookies

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

Seeds from the Sunflower State star in this crunchy favorite, along with rolled oats and shredded coconut. The recipe is from a Mulberry, Kansas, reader.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

28 of 46

Hazelnut-Chocolate Chunk Cookies

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

We loaded these crisp and chewy chocolate chip cookies with white and chocolate chips along with toasted hazelnuts.

29 of 46

Strawberry-Coconut Thumbprints

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

Linda Roberts of Rapid City, South Dakota, tops her buttery cream cheese, coconut-coated cookie with fruit jam. 

30 of 46

Chocolate Nut Revels

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

A luscious chocolate and pecan mixture swirls throughout these festive cookies.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

31 of 46

Awesome Chocolate-Peanut Blowout Cookies

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

What makes these cookies so awesome? "Special ingredients," says the Marion, Ohio, reader who contributed the recipe, which includes chocolate and peanut butter. "I like them because they're decadent yet so easy to make."

32 of 46

Triple-Flavored Big-Batch Cookies

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

Chocolate chips, peanut butter and oatmeal pack these cookies from a Door County, Wisconsin, bed-and-breakfast. Because this recipe makes so many cookies, you might want to freeze some dough for future use. 

33 of 46

Valencia Delights

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

Orange and chocolate: a cookie match that tempts everyone to take seconds. This recipe comes from Jill Drury in Milwaukee, who loved to bake cookies with her grandmother. "For the longest time I couldn't decide which cookie I liked best, until one day Grandma had me mix my favorite flavors: chocolate and orange," she says.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

34 of 46

Pistachio Cranberry Icebox Cookies

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

These cookies from the Inn at Cedar Falls in Logan, Ohio, make a colorful treat anytime of year.

35 of 46

Chocolate Lovers' Oatmeal Delight

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

Crisp on the outside and fudgy on the inside, these easy drop cookies feature semisweet chocolate pieces as well as peanut butter-flavored pieces. Unsweetened cocoa powder punches up the chocolate flavor.

36 of 46

Lemon Hazelnut Sea Salt Cookies

View Recipe this link opens in a new tab

Many cookies call for just citrus zest, but these soft gems use a lot of juice, too, so they've got the same tart kick as lemon bars. They're a perfect match for hot tea. The recipe comes from The Birchwood Cafe Cookbook (University of Minnesota Press, $29.95).