Midwest Living Review
This top-notch cafe and bakery offers much more than cheesecake. Come for huge sandwiches, plump wraps, innovative soups, make-your-own salads and coffee drinks galore, plus scones, cookies, cannoli and, yes, cheesecake. About 100 different kinds, actually. Offerings range from the rather standard turtle and strawberry shortcake cheesecake to the more exotic peach praline and poppy seed almond.
Located in a strip mall in the Bay Park Square area just south of Lambeau Field, Cheese Cake Heaven doesn't look impressive from the street. But the warm and cozy interior welcomes customers with golden walls, bronzed tabletops and European-inspired artwork.
If you're coming for a meal, good luck. The menu is so extensive—and everything looks so good--you'll have a hard time deciding. Do you go for the turkey and sun-dried tomato cream wrap or the chicken Caesar pesto sandwich with ricotta ravolini vegetable soup? The beverage menu includes a small selection of beer and wine.
At $8.99, the burgers are the most expensive items on the menu. Cheesecake runs about $4 per slice, depending on flavor. Even if you’re too full for dessert, get one to go. You’ll thank us later.