Sweetwater Boating Supplies

Don't let the name fool you. You don't need to own a boat to stop at this convenient shop. On the main drag about four blocks from the lake, it has everything you need for a day at the beach, including inflatables, beach toys and bags, and souvenir T-shirts. It's the largest gift shop in downtown New Buffalo, and it's packed with fun beach-theme trinkets and children's toys. But if you are a boat owner, you'll also find life vests, lines and buoys.