Midwest Living Review
This historic inn, painstakingly renovated in the early '90s, boasts 20 guest rooms with private baths with amenities comparable to a hotel including free wi-fi. Timothy's Restaurant is so popular, the innkeepers can't guarantee the availability of common areas for guests because the lobby is shared by the restaurant. But don't worry, you can get away from the restaurant crowd by heading down to the inn's private beach just three blocks away. Rooms start at $110 per night; some weekends and holidays require a two-night minimum reservation.