Midwest Living Review
Brewster's delivers tasty Italian dishes in a cozy setting on the main street in downtown New Buffalo. In warm weather, the choice seats are in the courtyard, which is nicely secluded behind stone walls and trellises and features a large fountain in the center. There are also a limited number of indoor tables set in a space designed to evoke an Italian village, complete with a cobblestone floor and village murals on the walls. Several of the tables sit right beside the open kitchen/deli counter, which means it stays quite warm from the ovens, and you'll hear and see the dishwasher doing his job nearby. Couples will enjoy the dinner for two special, which comes with two salads, one pizza, one entre, two cookies and two post-dinner coffees for about $32. We particularly enjoyed the meatballs with pasta and a marinara popping with spices and fresh vegetables.