The Tin Fish | Midwest Living

The Tin Fish

300 W. Jennings St.
Newburgh  Indiana  47630
United States
(812) 490-7000
+ enlarge
1 of 3
Pause »
  • 1
    - Lisa McClintick
  • 2
    - Lisa McClintick
  • 3
    - Lisa McClintick

Midwest Living Review

Lisa McClintick
This fish-focused, family-friendly eatery in scenic Newburgh draws diners with its casual setting (indoors or out), affordable prices and proximity to the river town's popular general store.

With a laid-back feel, this order-at-the-counter restaurant specializes in grilled mahimahi tacos and three-piece fish-and-chips dinners. Other menu items include a spicy calamari burrito; po' boy sandwiches; a mixed-grill platter with salmon, swordfish, shrimp and scallops; or fried platters of just about anything -- oysters, frog legs and a variety of fish. Most items run $9.99 to $16.50. We liked the grilled mahimahi taco, served with shredded cheese, a slathering of fresh tomato salsa and drizzle of sour cream on a soft-shell tortilla. You can get it with a vinegar-based slaw on the side and crispy waffle fries. The decor pulls together rustic touches such as corrugated steel around the bar with fancier elements such as blue-glass pendant lights above it. If your appetite's light and the weather's warm, grab a cold martini and mini crab cakes for the patio or creamy desserts such as Key lime or peanut butter ice cream pies.

Add Your Comment