27 Great Midwest Pizzerias | Midwest Living
More
Close

27 Great Midwest Pizzerias

Explore the heart, history and oven-blistered perfection of 27 Midwest pizzerias. Then dig in.
Photo by Ashley Petry.

Our final 7: The rest of the menu

Split the pizza to save room for these extras.

Breadsticks (pictured) Garlic-and-Parm flavored and delivered with savory dipping sauces. Try them at Pizzology in Carmel, Indiana. See reviews and ratings. (317) 844-2550; pizzologyindy.com  

Butterscotch Budino A caramel-topped dessert that falls somewhere between crème brûlée and pudding. Try it at Harvest in Columbus, Ohio. See reviews and ratings. (614) 824-1769; harvestpizzeria.com
 
Arancini Balls of risotto stuffed with mozzarella and coated in tomato-basil sauce. Try them at Luigi’s “The Original” in Harrison Township, Michigan. See reviews and ratings. (586) 468-7711; luigisoriginal.com
 
Farmers Market Salad Whatever is in season, whether it be shaved fennel, watermelon or beets. Try it at Black Sheep in Minneapolis and Saint Paul. See reviews and ratings. blacksheeppizza.com
 
Ice Cream Classic frozen novelties are free to dine-in customers. How cute is that? Try them at Pizza Corner in Valley City, North Dakota. (701) 845-0104; pizzacorner.net
 
Gooey Butter Cake The indulgent St. Louis classic is moist as ever and made on-site. Try it at Waldo Pizza’s two locations in metro Kansas City, Missouri. See reviews and ratings. waldopizza.net
 
Chinese Cheesesticks Crispy egg-roll wrappers stuffed with melted mozzarella and served with marinara for dipping. Try them at Fong’s Pizza in Des Moines. See reviews and ratings. (515) 323-3333; fongspizza.com

 

 

Elk River, Minnesota: Pompeii Pizzeria

Frank Galli has just hand-stretched 40 pounds of fresh mozzarella in anticipation of the dinner rush at his small-town pizza parlor. Frank’s path to get to this moment is paved with good ingredients. He founded both a bread bakery and a mushroom supplier before attending the Vermont Institute of Artisan Cheese in 2009. A year later, he opened Pompeii, where pizzas come dressed in Sicilian olive oil, delicate tomato sauce and unique toppings. (Spring brings a creamy white pizza with asparagus, sun-dried tomatoes and spinach.) But the star is the crust, baked to chewy perfection in a 750-degree stone oven. See Midwest Living's review. (763) 633-1222; pompeiipizzeria.net

Detroit: Buddy’s Pizzeria

When you pass through the well-kept rear door of the original Buddy’s Pizzeria, you leave the surrounding neighborhood blight behind and enter a maze of award-covered hallways and dining rooms with checkered tablecloths. Buddy’s began serving deep-dish in the 1940s as a novelty to increase business. It worked. Fans still pile in for hefty square pizzas blanketed with tangy sauce and gooey mozzarella. No doubt, Buddy’s is a throwback, but they’ve also moved with the times. Chicken fajita pizza, featuring moist chicken, sweet onions and roasted peppers, is irresistible. See Midwest Living's review. (313) 892-9001; buddyspizza.com

Kearney, Nebraska: Trattoria Flippin’ Sweet

To anyone who has taken a road trip fueled by chips and gas-station coffee, Flippin’ Sweet should come as good news. In 2012, this spunky pizzeria brought its pillowy pies from nearby Holdrege to fancier digs in downtown Kearney. Located right off Interstate-80 two hours west of Lincoln, Flippin’ Sweet trips all the trendy triggers: chalkboard decor, drinks in Mason jars, payments on an iPhone—and humorously named pizzas, like the Fig Leaf, with arugula, bacon, pistachios, garlic and fig butter. (308) 991-2316; theflippinsweet.com

Ames, Iowa: Great Plains Sauce and Dough Company

A longtime favorite of the Iowa State University community, Great Plains is the breadbasket of the pizza world, a homey, unpretentious place where Parmesan comes powdered in shakers and getting your weekly carb dosage in an evening is just good manners. The whole wheat Denver-style crust most people order has a hearty, yeasty flavor and provides a solid (naysayers might say bricklike) base for zesty red sauce, traditional toppings and a flood of cheese. This is the stuff Freshman Fifteens are made of. See Midwest Living's review. (515) 232-4263; greatplainspizza.com

Grand Forks, North Dakota: Rhombus Guys

Here’s a tale. A coupla 18-year-olds wanted to build a smoothie stand on a snowmobile trailer. Halfway through, one said, “This thing isn’t square at all. It’s more like a rhombus.” And thus they christened their first business Smoothie Rhombus. They later ventured into pizza, and that’s how the best ’za in North Dakota was born. Really. Clearly these guys have a sense of humor, but even better, they make fantastic pizza. The menu lists 33 pies, including the meaty local-favorite T-Rex and the creamy wild mushroom with Alfredo sauce and caramelized onions. The beer list is outstanding to boot. See Midwest Living's review. (701) 787-7317; rhombuspizza.com

St. Louis: Cicero’s

Ask a local where to find the best pizza in St. Louis, and you’ll get 10 answers. That happens in a city proud of its immigrant roots and vibrant Italian neighborhood. But inevitably, Cicero’s pops up on those lists. It’s been a staple in The Loop since 1977 and, yes, it serves true St. Louis-style pizza (as well as fantastic hand-tossed pies). Try the shrimp scampi, with a rich garlic butter white wine sauce, shrimp, fresh parsley, Provel and mozzarella on a waferlike crust. See Midwest Living's review. (314) 862-0009; ciceros-stl.com 

Chicago: Gino’s East and Pat's Pizzeria

Gino's East (pictured) Started by three guys (two of whom were cab drivers) in 1966, Gino’s has 11 locations in two states, plus a mail-order business, all built on the reputation of its Chicago-style pizza. The atmosphere isn’t special (aside from being allowed to write on the walls at the E. Superior Street flagship), but the pizza delivers: crispy-chewy, copious amounts of stretchy mozzarella, spicy pepperoni and bright red sauce. If you aren’t a deep-dish lover, Gino’s East’s just might be the pie that converts you. See Midwest Living's review.  ginoseast.com

Pat's Pizzeria Tourists and locals alike devour the city’s iconic deep-dish pizza, but thin-crust havens dot Chicago like perfectly spaced pepperoni. The best is Pat’s, a 63-year-old Lincoln Park hole-in-the-wall lined with Italian art posters, deep booths and year-round Christmas lights. Topping choices include scallops, giardiniera (pickled veggies), zucchini and legendary house-made Italian sausage. Surrounded by crisp edges and underlined with a barely there crust, each square will leave you craving another piece—which is more than can be said for its hefty cousin. See Midwest Living's review.  (773) 248-0168; patspizza.info

Milwaukee: Palermo’s villa-style factory

For a glimpse into your favorite frozen food, head just east of the Milwaukee Brewers ballpark. “First villa on the left,” says Palermo’s Pizza marketing director Chris Dresselhuys by way of directions.

Italian runs deep at Palermo’s, owned by a family that immigrated in the 1950s and later modeled their factory after a 16th-century Tuscan villa, complete with fountain.

“The Midwest is the epicenter of frozen pizza,” Chris says, looking at a production line that uses 1.63 million pounds of mozzarella a month and a conveyor-belt oven outfitted with slabs of Italian marble. On the tour, visitors watch towers of pepperoni fall in slices and smell the yeasty aroma of crusts rising on spiraling conveyors where they cool as they travel.

By the time guests reach the cafe at the end of the tour, they’re hungry for, of course, a free slice of hot Palermo’s pizza topped with flash-frozen veggies that pop on the palate like the pizza was, well, made right in front of you. Tour info: palermospizza.com

Fish Creek, Wisconsin: Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza and Grille

We love that proceeds from limited-edition Donation Creation pizzas go to local nonprofits. When we visited, it was a Middle Eastern pie with sweet-tart pomegranate seeds and feta cheese. See Midwest Living's review. (920) 868-3095; wildtomatopizza.com

Madison, Wisconsin: Ian’s Pizza

Best known for a ridiculously decadent mac and cheese pizza, this local chain with strong community spirit serves reasonably priced New York-style pies. You know the kind: Huge, thin, foldable triangles weepy with cheesy toppings that slide right down your chin upon first bite. Though there are plenty of “regular” toppings like pepperoni and sausage, adventurous ’za fans will never grow bored with Ian’s legendarily wacky monthly and weekly specials. Fish Fry pizza for carry-out, anyone? See Midwest Living's review. (608) 257-9248; ianspizza.com

Fairborn, Ohio: Giovanni’s Pizzeria e Ristorante Italiano

A fixture in downtown since 1953, Giovanni’s is a mom-and-pop restaurant that feels like a midcentury relic—in a good way. Though the Dayton-area restaurant has been under new ownership since the 1990s, the owners come from a long line of New York-Italian bakers. Strangers sit side by side at tables strung together in the middle of the dining room. The vaguely dated decor and unpretentious atmosphere perfectly complement the pizza, which is uncomplicated and utterly delicious: cornmeal-dusted crusts, plain red sauce and fadproof toppings like pepperoni, onions and, yes, canned mushrooms. If you venture off the pizza menu, try the sausage-stuffed banana peppers called Half/Hots. See Midwest Living's review. (937) 878-1611; giovannisfairborn.com

 

7 more pizzerias: Pizza toppings to try

The Mimi (pictured) Hot, garlicky crust topped with a Caprese salad of grape tomatoes, creamy mozzarella and basil. Try it at Punch Pizza’s seven Twin Cities locations. See Midwest Living’s review. punchpizza.com

No. 24 Jalapeño creamed corn, mozzarella, blue cheese, smoked beef brisket, sweet corn and red onion. Try it at Gusto Pizza Co. in Des Moines. See Midwest Living’s review.  (515) 244-8786; gustopizzaco.com

Pizza alla Quattro Formaggio Romano, cheddar, ricotta, mozzarella, provolone, bacon and mushroom. Try it at Bazbeaux’s three metro Indianapolis locations. See Midwest Living’s review. bazbeaux.com

Bacon and Potato White sauce, potatoes, bacon, spinach and Gorgonzola. Try it at New Holland Brewing Company in Holland, Michigan. See Midwest Living’s review.  (616) 355-6422; newhollandbrew.com

Spinoccoli Broccoli, spinach, mozzarella, cheddar and Parmesan-garlic white sauce. Try it at Mother Bear’s Pizza in Bloomington, Indiana. See Midwest Living’s review. (812) 332-4495; motherbearspizza.com

Six Ways from Sunday Chicken, garlic, peppers, spinach, tomatoes, mozzarella and feta. Try it at Six Hundred Downtown in Bellefontaine, Ohio. See Midwest Living’s review.  (937) 599-6600; 600downtown.com

Scarborough Fair Pepperoni, sausage, veggies—and parsley, sage, rosemary and thyme. Try it at Dough Trader Pizza Co. in Spearfish, South Dakota. (605) 642-2175; doughtrader.com

Our final 7: The rest of the menu

Split the pizza to save room for these extras.

Breadsticks (pictured) Garlic-and-Parm flavored and delivered with savory dipping sauces. Try them at Pizzology in Carmel, Indiana. See reviews and ratings. (317) 844-2550; pizzologyindy.com  

Butterscotch Budino A caramel-topped dessert that falls somewhere between crème brûlée and pudding. Try it at Harvest in Columbus, Ohio. See reviews and ratings. (614) 824-1769; harvestpizzeria.com
 
Arancini Balls of risotto stuffed with mozzarella and coated in tomato-basil sauce. Try them at Luigi’s “The Original” in Harrison Township, Michigan. See reviews and ratings. (586) 468-7711; luigisoriginal.com
 
Farmers Market Salad Whatever is in season, whether it be shaved fennel, watermelon or beets. Try it at Black Sheep in Minneapolis and Saint Paul. See reviews and ratings. blacksheeppizza.com
 
Ice Cream Classic frozen novelties are free to dine-in customers. How cute is that? Try them at Pizza Corner in Valley City, North Dakota. (701) 845-0104; pizzacorner.net
 
Gooey Butter Cake The indulgent St. Louis classic is moist as ever and made on-site. Try it at Waldo Pizza’s two locations in metro Kansas City, Missouri. See reviews and ratings. waldopizza.net
 
Chinese Cheesesticks Crispy egg-roll wrappers stuffed with melted mozzarella and served with marinara for dipping. Try them at Fong’s Pizza in Des Moines. See reviews and ratings. (515) 323-3333; fongspizza.com

 

 

Make your own pizza

In the mood to make your own pizza? Click in the Related Links box for some of our best pizza recipes, including Pizza Margherita, BBQ Chicken Grilled Pizza, Chicago-Style Deep-Dish Pizza and Fresh Veggie Pizza. 

Reheating 101: Whether you bought or made your pizza, say good-bye to soggy microwaved leftovers. For a crispy crust, let pizza come to room temperature. Warm slices in a covered, heavy-bottomed skillet over medium-low heat. (Lower the temperature if the crust crisps before toppings are hot.) To reheat more than a couple of slices, use the oven.

Add Your Comment